Worn examples fetch around $60–$91, but pristine uncirculated survivors can command $400–$527 or more. With only ~600 proof coins struck, a high-grade proof is among the most prized Indian Head cents of the decade. Use the free tools below to identify your coin's grade, variety, and true market value.
★★★★★ Rated 4.8/5 by 1,247 collectors · Updated with PCGS auction data · 2026 edition
Check My 1868 Indian Head Penny Value →The 1868 proof Indian Head Penny is the signature variety collectors hunt for. With only around 600 struck, a genuine proof is instantly worth $200–$1,000+ depending on grade. Use this quick checker to assess your coin.
Left: typical business strike — Right: proof issue with mirror fields & squared rims
Rounded rims, slightly uneven strike sharpness. Fields show die flow lines or contact marks under magnification. Hair detail above ear and feather tips may show softness. Surface color runs from brown (BN) to red-brown (RB). Worth $60–$527 depending on grade.
Fully squared, wire rims. Brilliant mirror-like (cameo) fields with sharply frosted raised devices. Date and LIBERTY stand out with crisp, razor-sharp edges. Every feather tip and hair strand is fully defined. Color is either brown (BN) or red-brown (RB); full red proofs are exceptionally rare. Worth $200–$1,000+ depending on grade and color.
Type a description of your coin below. Our analyzer will scan for key variety markers, grade clues, and condition flags to give you a tailored value assessment.
Skipped the calculator? Enter your mint mark, condition, and any errors to get an instant estimated value range — it only takes 30 seconds.
Use the Free Calculator →Follow the three steps below. The calculator uses real collector price data to estimate your coin's current market value.
If you're unsure about your coin's grade or errors, there's a free 1868 Indian Head Penny Coin Value Checker online tool that lets you upload photos and get an AI-powered estimate without needing to know grades in advance.
Everything you need to know about the 1868 Indian Head Penny in one place.
The 1868 Indian Head Penny has 18 cataloged die varieties according to CONECA and indianvarieties.com. The four categories below cover the most actively traded error types, from repunched dates that sell with regularity to scarcer die clashes. Each card includes what to look for with a 10× loupe and why collectors pay a premium.
Repunched date errors on the 1868 Indian Head Penny occurred when the date was punched into the working die in two or more separate operations, with the second punch landing slightly offset from the first. Because date punches were applied by hand at the Philadelphia Mint in this era, misalignment was common, and 1868 has 18 cataloged die varieties — more than most issues of its decade.
Under a 10× loupe, the telltale sign is a secondary shadow impression of one or more digits sitting below, above, or beside the primary numeral. The first and last "8" in 1868 are most frequently repunched, though the "1" shows offset doubling on certain varieties. The doubling is mechanically precise — the digits are clearly complete but misaligned, distinguishing an RPD from worn or damaged numerals.
Collectors are drawn to 1868 RPD varieties because they add documented interest to a date that is already considered scarce in all grades. A problem-free circulated RPD can sell for a meaningful premium over a plain example of the same grade. Certified RPD examples graded F-15 or better by PCGS or NGC attract the most competitive bidding.
A doubled die obverse on the 1868 Indian Head Penny results from a working hub imparting its design to the working die in two separate hubbing operations, with the die rotating slightly between them. Unlike machine doubling — which produces a flat, shelf-like shadow — a true DDO creates a fully rounded, raised secondary impression of the design elements offset from the primary.
On the 1868 DDO, look for distinct doubling most prominently in the LIBERTY inscription running through the headdress band. The individual letters may appear as two slightly offset complete letters stacked or spread. The date may also show secondary digit outlines. The separation between primary and secondary elements must be clearly visible under a 10× loupe. Machine doubling shows no relief on the secondary impression and carries no premium.
True DDOs are rarer than RPD varieties on the 1868 cent and attract premium collector interest because they represent a manufacturing-stage error at the hub-die level — harder to produce than a simple repunched date. Verified DDO examples in grades of F-12 to EF-45 command notably higher prices than plain-strike equivalents. A certified DDO in VF-30 can sell for multiple times the standard price guide value for that grade.
A die clash occurs when the obverse and reverse dies strike each other without a planchet between them, leaving incuse impressions of each die's design on the opposing die. Subsequent strikes with the clashed dies transfer ghost images of the reverse design onto the obverse field, and vice versa. For the 1868 Indian Head Penny, die clashes are documented among its 18 cataloged varieties.
On a clashed 1868 cent, examine the open field areas on the obverse — the space in front of and behind Liberty's portrait — for faint incuse outlines of the reverse wreath curves or lettering from ONE CENT. On the reverse, look for traces of the portrait or headdress feathers impressed into the wreath or field area. The impressions appear as mirror-image ghost lines incused into the otherwise flat field surface.
Die clash varieties appeal to collectors because they tell a dramatic story about a production mishap at the Philadelphia Mint. The premium above a normal strike depends on the severity and visibility of the clash marks — strong, clearly visible clashes are worth considerably more. Moderately clashed examples sell reliably in the $80–$200 range for circulated grades, while strongly clashed, problem-free specimens push higher at specialty auctions.
Off-center and misaligned die (MAD) strikes on the 1868 Indian Head Penny result from a planchet being incorrectly positioned in the collar or from a die being offset from its proper axis before striking. The result is a design that is visibly displaced from the geometric center of the coin, leaving a visible crescent of blank planchet copper on one or more edges. Surviving examples from the 1860s are genuinely uncommon.
The degree of off-center displacement dramatically affects value. A minor 5–10% shift is interesting but modest in premium; a 20–30% shift that still retains the complete date is highly desirable to error collectors. Any off-center strike where the date is visible commands a premium — dateless off-centers have reduced collector appeal. The blank crescent area should have the same natural patina as the rest of the coin, distinguishing a genuine strike error from post-mint alteration.
True off-center 1868 Indian Head cents are among the rarest physical errors in the series because quality control at the 19th-century Philadelphia Mint was relatively stringent for its era. Surviving examples represent coins that escaped inspection. A strongly off-center (20%+) 1868 cent with a visible, complete date and original surfaces can attract competitive bidding from both Indian cent specialists and U.S. error coin collectors, pushing realized prices well above $400–$800 in strong markets.
Think you've spotted one of these errors? Run it through the value calculator — select your mint, condition, and check the relevant error box to get an instant estimated value range.
Calculate My Error Coin's Value →The table below summarizes collector market values across major strike types and grade levels. For an in-depth illustrated step-by-step 1868 Indian Head Penny identification guide and reference, the CoinValueApp resource covers every grade tier with photos and detailed diagnostics. Values reflect current market estimates based on PCGS auction data and dealer price guides — individual coins may vary based on eye appeal, surface quality, and certification status.
| Variety / Strike Type | Worn (Good G-4) | Circulated (F–XF) | Uncirculated (MS-60/63 BN) | Gem (MS-65 RD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Business Strike — Regular | ~$60 | $90 – $150 | $400 – $527 | $3,000+ |
| ⭐ Proof Strike (BN/RB) | N/A | ~$200 (PF-60) | $400 – $700 | $1,000+ |
| Repunched Date (RPD) | $75 – $100 | $110 – $200 | $450 – $600 | Premium varies |
| Doubled Die Obverse (DDO) | $90 – $150 | $150 – $350 | $500 – $800 | Premium varies |
| 🔴 Off-Center / MAD Strike | $150 – $250 | $250 – $500 | $500 – $800+ | Rare — check auction |
| Die Clash Variety | $80 – $120 | $120 – $250 | $400 – $600 | Scarce — check auction |
⭐ = Signature variety (most searched). 🔴 = Rarest category. Values are estimates; always verify against current PCGS Price Guide and recent completed sales.
🪙 CoinKnow is a fast on-the-go way to photograph your 1868 Indian Head Penny and cross-check its estimated value against current market data — a coin identifier and value app.
A range of 1868 Indian Head Penny grades — from heavily worn Good to near-mint Uncirculated
| Mint | Strike Type | Mintage | Survival Estimate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Philadelphia (P) | Business Strike | 10,266,500 | Many circulated; MS-65 RD extremely rare |
| Philadelphia (P) | Proof | ~600 | Several hundred; high-grade examples rare |
| Total 1868 Production | ~10,267,100 | All from Philadelphia Mint only | |
Note: The 1868 cent is described by PCGS numismatist David Hall as "scarce in all grades and rare in MS-65 RD or better condition" and "approximately equal in rarity to the 1866 and 1867 issues." Branch-mint marks on cents did not appear until 1908-S, so all 1868 cents are Philadelphia issues with no mint mark on the coin itself.
Left to right: Good → Fine → Extremely Fine → Uncirculated. Color and feather detail are the key grading markers.
The outline of the portrait and headdress is visible but feather tips are mostly flat and merged. LIBERTY in the headdress band is readable but worn smooth. The date is clear. Rim may be slightly flat on high points. Surface color is uniformly dark brown. Value: around $60.
LIBERTY reads fully and clearly; individual feather tips show increasing separation as grade improves toward XF. Hair above Liberty's ear shows moderate to light wear. The reverse wreath retains leaf detail with visible ribbing in EF. Even brown or red-brown color is a strong positive. Value: $90–$150 in this range.
No wear on the high points under magnification, though contact marks, bag marks, and handling marks will be present. Surface luster has turned brown (BN) from oxidation but the design is complete and sharp. Feather tips are individually defined. Value: approximately $400–$527 in BN grades at this level.
Exceptional eye appeal with minimal contact marks. Original mint red luster covers 95%+ of both surfaces. Strike is sharp with all feather tips and hair strands fully defined. These are genuinely rare survivors — the 1868 cent in full red gem condition represents one of the most challenging dates in the series. Value: several thousand dollars and up.
📸 CoinKnow lets you photograph your 1868 Indian Head Penny and match its surface condition against graded examples in its reference database — a coin identifier and value app.
The right sales venue depends on your coin's grade and how quickly you need to sell. Here's an honest breakdown of your four main options:
Best for coins graded MS-62 or better, certified proofs, and notable error varieties. Heritage reaches the largest pool of serious Indian cent collectors. Expect a seller's fee of around 10–15%. Best realized prices for high-grade and rare specimens. Allow 2–3 months from submission to settlement.
Ideal for circulated examples in the $60–$200 range. To see what comparable coins have recently sold for, browse actual sold prices for 1868 Indian Head Pennies in current listings to calibrate your asking price. Use "Sold" filter to see completed transactions, not active listings.
Offers convenience and immediate cash payment — usually within 24–48 hours. Expect to receive 50–70% of retail book value, which is the trade-off for speed and simplicity. A useful option for well-worn examples worth $60–$100 where auction and shipping fees would eat into returns.
Good for mid-range circulated examples. The /r/Coins4Sale community allows direct peer-to-peer transactions with no fees. Buyers expect honest grading and clear photos. Build feedback before listing high-value coins. Best suited for F–XF examples in the $80–$200 range where eBay fees aren't worth it.
It takes under 60 seconds. Select your mint, grade, and any errors — and get your instant estimate now.
Use the Free Calculator Now →